The Top 5 Best Amanita Muscaria Gummies in 2024

In 2024, buying magic mushrooms online remains a legal gamble, and most places aren't looking to make a significant change to their laws anytime soon.

In the meantime, more and more people are using Amanita muscaria for legal mushroom experiences instead. It’s legal throughout Canada, Europe, and the United States (except Louisiana).

Amanita mushrooms produce muscimol, a psychoactive compound that’s effective for most folks starting at doses of 10 mg, although everyone reacts differently.

Searching online marketplaces for legal shrooms is entering unchartered territory. It’s hard to know what’s in each product, and even when manufacturers claim to have products lab-tested, we have no way to verify the claims.

Top 5 Best Amanita Gummies in 2024

Some products are well made, though. The companies are reputable and have proven they’re trustworthy. 

Here are some of the Amanita gummy brands we love the most:

1. Area 52 Magic Pluto Mushroom Gummies (Best Overall)

2. Royal CBD Amanita Mushroom +THC Gummies (Runner Up)

3. YUMZ Amanita Muscaria Mushroom Gummies (Best Low Dose)

4. Mushroom Lyfe Amanita Gummies (Honorable Mention)

5. Premium Jane Amanita Muscaria Gummies

#1: Area 52 Magic Pluto Mushroom Gummies (Best Overall)

On the top shelf of Amanita gummies sits Area 52’s psychedelic Magic Pluto Mushroom Gummies.  

The muscimol extract used to produce these gummies is crafted from wild-harvested Amanita mushrooms and is combined with Area 52's well-known and federally compliant “UFO” hemp extract. They’ve added a blend of other ingredients to create a balanced gummy that surpasses the competition.

While other products contain very little or massive amounts of muscimol, Area 52 has engineered a fusion of ingredients that potentiate the effects of muscimol while keeping the experience smooth and pleasant.

Area 52 gummies contain:

• Muscimol - Psychoactive extract from Amanita mushrooms

• Full-Spectrum Hemp Extract - For maximum calm and a gentle focus

• Blue Lotus Flower - Heightens the dreamy effects 

• Dream Herb - Mexican herb also working in synergy for trance-like states

• L-Theanine - Promotes focus and energy

• Ashwagandha - Adaptogenic effects contribute to mellow mood and wellbeing

• 5-HTP - Balances shifting serotonin levels

• Vitamin B6 - Regulates serotonin, dopamine, and GABA, neurotransmitters controlling mood

Pros & Cons of Area 52 Magic Pluto Gummies: 

• PRO: Well-known and loved brand

• PRO: Complete nootropic stack

• PRO: Lab testing on every batch

• CON: Only available in cherry flavor is available

#2: Royal Amanita Mushroom + THC Gummies (Runner Up)

Amanita mushrooms pair nicely with cannabis. Royal has leveraged their experience with cannabis extract gummies to make an even stronger mind-altering gummy by mixing their well-renowned full-spectrum hemp extract (standardized to 10 mg delta-9 THC and 25 mg CBD per gummy) with an amanita muscaria extract. All are perfectly legal under federal law (some state-specific exceptions apply, listed on the company’s website).

These gummies are strong — very strong. Yet the price is on par, with much weaker products flooding the market right now.

Royal is well-known for producing premium quality products at a discount. Pick yourself up a bag while supplies last (they sell out often).

Pros & Cons of Royal Amanita Mushroom + THC Gummies: 

• PRO: High dose 10 mg muscimol + 10 mg D9 THC

• PRO: Extensive third-party testing available online.

• PRO: Hundreds of 5-star reviews despite new release.

• CON: Only available in the US.

#3: YUMZ Amanita Muscaria Mushroom Gummies

Wild-harvested Amanita muscaria from Lithuania YUMZ posted lab reports on their website showing 10.14 mg of active ingredients in each gummy.

These are entirely vegan and devoid of ibotenic acid, the compound in Amanita that causes digestive discomfort. YUMZ comes in mixed berry, watermelon, and mango flavors.

YUMZ advises caution, recommending users start with a low dosage to ensure safety. 

Pros & Cons of YUMZ Amanita Muscaria Gummies: 

• PRO: Solid 10 mg of muscimol

• PRO: No ibotenic acid

• CON: Can’t find reviews in the online store

• CON: It seems like not all Amanita products undergo testing

#4: Mushroom Lyfe Euphoric Amanita Gummies

Mushroom Lyfe harnesses lab-engineered muscimol for its gummies, which undergo third-party lab testing. Their formula is crafted to induce a surge of 'mind energy' and is available in enticing apple green and purple punch flavors.

While each gummy weighs 600 mg, Mushroom Lyfe doesn't provide specific details regarding the muscimol content per unit.

Mushroom Lyfe does encourage safe use and waiting a period between doses to watch for effects. You can always take more, not less.

Pros & Cons of Mushroom Lyfe Euphoric Amanita Gummies: 

• PRO: Blends with cannabinoids

• PRO: Green apple flavor is good

• CON: Unclear about how much muscimol is in gummies

• CON: Cannot find reviews

#5: Premium Jane Amanita Muscaria Gummies

Initially established as a CBD brand, Premium Jane has been moving into the mushroom business by introducing gummies boasting 500 mg of muscimol extract, or about 10 mg each.

Containing only Amanita extract and D9 THC, Premium Jane’s gummies are 100% free of psilocybin, like all the other gummies on this list.

Pros & Cons of Premium Jane Amanita Gummies

• PRO: Peach raspberry is tasty

• PRO: Blend with Delta 9 available

• CON: Low amount of muscimol

• CON: It is super hard to locate Amanita in the online store

#6: Cheef Botanicals Amanita Gummy Cubes

Dedicated to delivering premium products, Cheef strives for quality gummy cubes with third-party lab testing. 

Cheef Botanicals' gummies and softgels feature 5 mg of muscimol from 500 mg of Amanita fruiting body extract.

Cheef instills confidence that each cube contains precisely the advertised amount — each package is equipped with a QR code for easy access to detailed lab test results.

Pros & Cons of Cheef Botanicals Amanita Gummy Cubes: 

• PRO: QR code seamlessly links to lab tests

• PRO: Vegan and gluten-free

• CON: No mixtures with cannabinoids 

• CON: Less muscimol than some brands

Are Magic Mushrooms Legal?

Magic mushrooms grow naturally around the world, but the compound inside them, psilocybin, is illegal. 

In the United States, buying magic mushrooms online is not a good idea. Law enforcement can track packages of psilocybin mushrooms being mailed. Getting caught bringing mushrooms from decriminalized cities to other regions can get folks in serious trouble. Penalties can include fines and jail time, depending on the amount of mushrooms.

Other countries, like Canada and parts of Europe, are more lenient than the United States despite mushrooms being illegal. Some packages might be intercepted, and law enforcement is within their rights to prosecute, but this seems rare. 

Nonetheless, an abundance of shroom shops are opening. Some exist online and others in person, giving the false sense there is an open market for mushrooms —  but even in decriminalized areas of North America, these are all grey and black market operations. 

The exception is in parts of the world where mushrooms have never been made illegal or decriminalized. States like Oregon and Colorado are experimenting with legal access to mushrooms, but currently, personal use or buying from a dispensary is not an option. In these states, psilocybin mushrooms can only be taken with licensed facilitators.

Other countries, like Jamaica or the Netherlands, have legal loopholes allowing mushroom use and purchase.

Amanita Muscaria: The Legal Magic Mushroom

Amanita muscaria is the world's most iconic mushroom. Known as fly agaric, this mushroom has long held a particular spot in folk culture.

The red cap with white spots is the quintessential mushroom. Amanita changes the size of Super Mario on Super Nintendo and is a symbol found in the strangely psychedelic book and movie Alice in Wonderland. There are even theories that the red and white costume of Santa Claus was inspired by the outfits of Siberian shamans known to use fly agaric for divination and healing.

For a long time, it has been assumed that Amanita is poisonous. There are different types of Amanita, and some do have excess amounts of a substance called ibotenic acid, which is toxic. Taking too much can be dangerous, and some have had to go to the hospital for eating the wrong mushroom, but there has not been a reported Amanita death for 100 years.

The trick to safely consuming Amanita is preparing it properly. When dried thoroughly, much of the ibotenic acid turns into muscimol, and further boiling in acidic water for hours converts more into muscimol.

Muscimol works in several ways in the body. As a cholinergic, it interacts with the acetylcholine receptors in the body, which are connected to the parasympathetic system — the part of the nervous system responsible for calming us down — which leads to sedating effects. Muscimol also has a structure similar to GABA, a neurotransmitter known as the "breaks pedals of the brain" and known to have mellowing and antianxiety effects. These may explain some of Amanita’s effects, but in truth, scientists don't know precisely how the psychedelic effects of Amanita come about and are still learning.

What’s the Best Dose for Amanita Mushrooms?

The best dose of Amanita will be different for everyone. Previously, dosing Amanita meant how big or how many mushrooms you ate. 

For an average psychoactive dose, about three average-sized caps are thought to do the trick. Dosing with whole mushrooms can be challenging because of the variable amounts of muscimol. 

Extracts and modern science make dosing much easier. Research tells us that a psychoactive dose is about 8 to 15 mg of muscimol, but everyone responds a bit differently. Start by taking half a gummy and wait at least 60 minutes for the effects. It's important to wait a long time between doses, as it can take over three hours for Amanita to take effect in some cases.

Some folks aren't looking for a full psychoactive experience but instead to optimize their daily lives by microdosing. A microdose is usually about 10% of a psychoactive dose taken on a regular schedule to achieve benefits over time.

More experienced psychonauts have pushed the upper limits of Amanita for more immersive and intense experiences. These often come with nausea, vomiting, loss of motor skills, and seriously strange experiences like passing out and having wild, confusing dreams. These higher doses are much closer to psychedelic trips but also come with significant risks. We don't recommend trying to play shaman.

Amanita Mushrooms vs. Psilocybe Mushrooms: Similarities & Differences Explained

Both Amanita muscaria and psilocybin mushrooms have psychoactive properties, but their effects are pretty different. Few would debate psilocybin’s status as a psychedelic, but the jury is still out on Amanita. 

Psilocybin is an unmistakable state of mind where events take on deep meaning, and emotions become amplified. Music and art can take on new qualities, and hallucinations like melting surfaces or colorful geometry can appear. Both deep acceptance and overwhelming anxiety can be part of psilocybin mushrooms, sometimes all at the same time.

Some might call Amanita muscaria psychedelic, but we prefer the term psychoactive. Perceptions do become altered, but it’s a bit like a dream. If you have ever had a lucid dream, which is the experience of becoming aware you are dreaming, Amanita is somewhat similar to that. Objects may change size and shape, but not like the hallucinations of other psychedelics. Overall, with the doses found in gummies, the effect is considerably more low-key and calming than psilocybin.

Where do Amanita Mushrooms Grow Naturally?

Amanita muscaria is native to the forests of the Northern Hemisphere, like the United States, Canada, Europe, Russia, China, and many other countries. The mushroom prefers cooler, temperate environments but grows naturally at high elevations in warmer climates — like mountainous regions of Central America or in warmer areas of the world at high elevations, such as in the Hindu Kush in the Himalayas. 

Amanita has a symbiotic relationship with certain trees, meaning it partners with them to exchange benefits. The Amanita mycelium, which is its root, connects with those of pine, oak, spruce, birch, and cedar trees. Through this connection, the tree gives the mushroom sugars, while the mushroom helps the tree get more nutrients and water. 

Humans like the same trees as Amanita and have brought them around the world with them, planting them in Africa, Australia, and South America. Because Amanita spores and mycelium were in the roots of some of these trees, it now grows far beyond its natural range.

Because of this special relationship to trees, many mushroom hunters will look for specific species of trees when foraging. The relationship also makes it difficult to cultivate Amanita in artificial environments. Most of the muscimol in these gummies comes from wild-harvested Amanita and is then extracted. Some researchers have grown Amanita outside of the forest, but the process isn’t super efficient.

How to Avoid Scams When Buying Amanita Muscaria Products

Unfortunately, when shopping for Amanita muscaria for sale online, you’re inevitably going to run into a lot of scams. 

The contents of a product can be suspect, or sometimes you get nothing for your money. But with some research, buying high-quality Amanita muscaria gummies online can be done safely.

• Product reviews - If a company has no reviews, it is a red flag. If there are only a few reviews saying the same thing, they could be fake. Browse products on the website and look for products with hundreds of positive reviews, which is challenging for companies to fake.

• Third-Party Reviews - Check out other platforms like Reddit or Facebook to see if people are discussing the product you are interested in. If something is a scam or of poor quality, people will often post about it online.

• Trustpilot.com - This website is a place where people can go to rate products and services they find online. Check out the domain or company name you are sourcing products from and see what kind of reviews appear. 

• Customer Support  - Figuring out if real humans are running a website can screen out scams, but remember, it's also pretty easy to pretend to be caring customer service. Still, this can help stay clear of automated scams.

When reading reviews, look for lab test reports that companies have posted. Companies invested in their customer's health test their products for potency or purity. While it is tough to tell if these tests are for the specific batch of the product, test results are worth a glance.

Some shady brands add other compounds like synthetic cannabinoids or compounds not on the label. For some people, these can cause unwanted effects, so read carefully to see if anyone has reacted negatively to a product or gotten way higher than expected. 

Amanita FAQ Section

It's impossible to cover everything, but here are answers to people's common questions. 

1. What Effects Can I Expect from Consuming Amanita Shroom Gummies?

After consuming Amanita expect a dreamy, lucid sensation and perhaps a bit of distorted vision, with the shape of objects changing. Perception of time can get mixed up, too.

Amanita shroom gummies make some people sleepy and cause them to have strange dreams. Many people seek out Amanita for these oneirogenic or ‘dream-inducing’ effects, especially to induce lucid dreams. However, be warned, Amanita's dreams can get pretty crazy.

2. How Long Do the Effects of Amanita Shroom Gummies Last?

Amanita gummies often take 2 hours or 3 hours to take effect. Because of this long wait, it’s essential to wait lots of time between doses — you don’t want to take too much too fast.

After about 5 hours or so, the effects will peak, although some people feel the effects for up to twelve hours later. Bigger doses seem to make the effects last longer.

3. Can Amanita Shroom Gummies Be Used for Microdosing?

Yes, many people love microdosing Amanita shroom gummies. The dream-like effects are gentle and don’t provoke anxiety as easily as psilocybin microdoses. 

The sense of calm from Amanita makes it a preferred microdosing substance for many. Some will take microdoses before bed to induce lucid dreams.

A microdose is a sub-perceptual dose of a psychoactive substance. Finding the right microdose with Amanita may take some experimentation. If you know your threshold for a psychoactive dose, a microdose is about one-tenth of that. 

Gummies can be sliced up to give approximate doses, or some folks get a feel for taking tiny bites.

4. Can Amanita Shroom Gummies Interact With Other Medications?

Yes, Amanita gummies can interact with other medications. If you are taking any medication, consult with a medical professional before taking any psychoactive substance. 

Amanita could make some medications stronger or weaker, while some medications could make Amanita’s effects more or less powerful.

5. Is It Possible to Overdose on Amanita Shroom Gummies?

Yes, it’s theoretically possible to overdose on Amanita gummies, but you would need to take a considerable amount. 

People with serious cardiovascular, liver, or kidney problems should consult with a medical professional before consuming Amanita gummies. Avoid any psychoactive substances if you have a history of mania or schizophrenia.